Toppers' CopiesPYQ

GS Paper 4 Toppers' Copies

All questions · 324 questions

  1. Open question 1021
    Q251 · 10 MARKS

    Don't write VAJIRAM & RAV! ae S. (a) Many artists argue thai censorship giifles creativy. How can policyaiukers ethically balance artistic freedom with soc cictal standards of decency" Justify your answer (10 marks 160 words)

    Topper: Reshma Nivetha · AIR 498 · 2025 · Page 14

  2. Open question 1022
    Q252 · 10 MARKS

    Eph. Athavious vs gatandtoed dedision me whis ol Aarne 2 Sian inl fint ' toubtic trvat? ~ = ~ i. ~ (10 marks 150 words)

    Topper: Reshma Nivetha · AIR 498 · 2025 · Page 16

  3. Open question 1023
    Q253 · 10 MARKS

    on of human dignity vllen ie contest dni sa ool y oll & a ts plagued by excessive force and cust a F == Hse Vo ca wunomtis yy vil ents rosalve such valuc confls while maintaining hoth nar amd public order' (10 marks 150 words)

    Topper: Reshma Nivetha · AIR 498 · 2025 · Page 20

  4. Open question 1024
    Q254 · 20 MARKS

    Don't write anything in tive part) (Don't write anything in tiie part) asl fovelopmey ' 7.10 afdrought prone districh Phe government has approved wnal de 1 accom iseesiodacly to the (Tan TomnaTod RTS sed exclusiog from irrigation se schemes However as the canal sir T cs throug tla ayy lee group of infhuential villagers begins opposing the project They block construction vehicles fil fnvolous egal objections and claim the canal alignment encrmaches on their community lands even though surveys show olbemwias } > obstructions are rooted inlsocial prejudiccjand fear of lower control over local water resources rf margmalied comununrities + } et ® Tew contractors have aon ae pO nee conc] to escalating tensions. The Dalit farmers are growing restless and have submitted oe ne & memorandum alleging conumunity based obstruction of development and state ee Lot development project oreo ensure Local officials report that thes failure The District Magistrate is ow faced with the challenge of ensuring unmicrrupied development maintaining law and order and ypholding constitutional values of social justice and equality OCHA JUSHCS ANG COR (a) Discuss the ethical dilemmas faced by the District Magistrate (bh) Enumerate all the options available@@ pe District Magistrat handlin this situation effectively. (c) What actions can be taken to ensure inclusive development while preventing social unrest? (20 marks 250 wards)

    Topper: Reshma Nivetha · AIR 498 · 2025 · Page 22

  5. Open question 1025
    Q255 · 20 MARKS

    Don't write anything tn is parry (Don't write VAJIRAM & RAV! ying Uve part) = You are posted istrict Collector of a cos hatis inthe diccet path of Cyclone Saga yr a Category 5 storm expected to np make ~tandf ill within 16 hours. The iochan Meteorolorical Department has issued a red alert warning oLyntense winds DHT SUITES anid potential Tooding. You cnancible for leading th souation ofnearly 2 lakh people from vul hI areas. However several fisiing hamlets along the coast refuse to leave. They tear losing their boats nets and Tivs stock th cironly means of livelihood. Memones of } ' ' '. distrustful of of 'official assummmces The district's relief resources are already stretched. Several yclone shelters lack ut cycrone as oh POUT SUCTI as Tle Clean wallet of prvi " i) Snaeeeneemgtt cess ". pean Emergency Tands alloc Sed t by the state have not yet tia fully released hampe ymipering procurement of essential supplies Local NGOs have r aiged these issues publicly cies h i d eetra) SuUpptics Loca further influcucing people's reluctance to evacuate Meanwhile. 9 senior hureaucrat has advised you to prioritize "visible evacuation isible evaeu zones" (0 ensure positive media coverage. On the ground your team ts divided TL VOANOCIR COVETRS some officers anzic for a coercive approach to save lives while others caustic on] ome oficcrs yereive por hile ot ga 2 the community game? atcnay Fa! > (a) What are the core ethical issues involved in this situation? (b) in such trying circumstances what will be your response (c) What values and leadership traits are essential for a public servant in such a crisis? (20 marks 250 words)

    Topper: Reshma Nivetha · AIR 498 · 2025 · Page 26

  6. Open question 1026
    Q256 · 20 MARKS

    Don't write (Don't write seein VAJIRAM & RAV! roe this part) 9 Kirti and Nilesh childhood trends from a small town in Maharashtra had always stood by each other through life's ups and downs Both dreamed of becoming doctors. but their academic tourneys diverged. Kirti cleared the NEFT exam in her first attempt and joined a reputed medical college in Mumbai. Nilesh despite being equally capable had to drop a year due to family responsibilities and joined the same college a year later By the time Nilesh reached his final year Kirti had already begun her internship and was appointed as the student coordingior for the Wpoomuns final year practical examinations. In this role she was responsible for coordinating logistics between faculty and students managing lab schedules and assisting with administrative picpanitiony icluding conlidcntial Waks like pholocopy ig and slong cAwminulon materials Around the same time Nilesh confided in her that he was on the verge of mental and emotional collapse. His father's prolonged illness had drained the family financially and he was juggling studies with d paiictine job. He admutted that the upcoming practicals would not only destroy his morale but also crush his family's hope. Kirti's parents recalling how Nilesh's family had once helped them dunng a emsis gently reminded fier thar "this tight be the time fo return the favour" Kart herself was torn she felt a deep personal sense of sratitude. Yet she was also acutely aware of the ¢thical responsibyities ©. Any breach of protocol inicntional or otherwise could compromise the faimess of the examination process and damage her integrity. Her mentoghad explicitly warmed her that even the perception of impropriety could lead to an ingwiry and serious consequences (a) What are the ethical dilemmas before Kirti in this case? (b) Identify and evaluate the various Courses of action available before Kuri (c) If you were in Kirti's shoes which course of action would you choose and why? (20 marks 250 words)

    Topper: Reshma Nivetha · AIR 498 · 2025 · Page 32

  7. Open question 1027
    Q257 · 20 MARKS

    Doopali amiidctexel dats scientist at SwiltKart has always taken pride in the platform's use of cutting edge technology to enhance customer experience She joined the company inxpired by its promise of digital innovation serving everyday needs However during a routine audit of pricing algorithms Deepali discovered a pattern that unsettled her deeply. Users accessing the app via high end smartphones were consistently being shown higher prices for fresh fruits and vegetaht mpared to those using budget devices even under identical conditions of location order contents and delivery address. While technically legal under the company's internal pricing policies the practice had never been disclosed to users. When deepal raised the issue m internal meetings the scmior management delended i ds a form of smart demund bused pricing" designed fo maximise profits in a competitive market. She was told that such differential preing helps balance margins without affecting lower income users However Deepali couldn't shake off the feeling that this amounted to digital profiling and subtle economic discrimination Matters escalated when the issue attracted public scrutiny following an exposé by a tech blog highlighting the pricing discrepancics. With increasing media coverage tnd & formal inguiy mitiated by the Consumer Pegieetion Authority Deepal « conscientious professional finds herself facing a serious cthical dilemma. The situation becomes more complex when she receives a subtle yet cautionary remark from her reponing manager advising hee to "avoid activism in public matters indirectly discouraging any further discussion or disclosure of the revere "hm (a) Discuss 'ethical dilemmas faced by Deepali. (b) What are the options available to Deepali to cope with the situation? (ce) you were in Deepali's position what course of action would you lake aud why? Justify your decision using ethical principles (d) Suggest a framework that technology based platforms can adopt to ensure ininspurency fairness tind ethiow! use of consumer dats in algorithm driven Services. (20 marks 250 words)

    Topper: Reshma Nivetha · AIR 498 · 2025 · Page 36

  8. Open question 1028
    Q258 · 20 MARKS

    Ma Rukinany is an upright ang) highly decors IPS IPS olllces with gepulaliontor mteenty and effective crisis muinayement particularly in conflict ridden areas. She "integrity ae Nt has recently heen appointed as the Superintendent of Police (SP) in District 'X'ofo PM ALLS B. frontier state This district is grappling with a rampant narcoles menace The drug wade has permeated every tacet of life in District economic disruption with widespread poppy cultivation replacing " taditional agriculture creating a parallel economy dnven by money laundering. There's a pt) 3 Ml tL well armed dguy See UMACHOANS I ETTTIS NITIES and the emerpenve uf cartels which often result in violent clashes involving sophisticated weaponry The district is also witnessing profound social decay evidenced by a devastating impact on pars health due to rampant drug addiction especially among the youth ational system is with rising cases of overdose and associated crime The edu = a ee virtually paralyzed as schools are being used for drug peddling or children are dropping out to join the drug trade leading to a lost generation There are strong albeit unconfirmed reports that several powerful local politicians including a sitting MLA who holds significant sway and a fee senior pai officers some evenabove your rank m the state cadfe tnd potentially your direct superiors are providing direct or indirect patronage to the drug mafia. This entrenched nexus makes effective law enforcement extremely difficult. The morale of the honest live is al an all time low with many feeling helpless or intimidaicd while public trust in the administration is completely croded and cynicism about the nue of law isssidespread (a) Identify the various ethical dilemmas Ms. Rukmani would confront in this complex situation (b) Outline courses of action available to Ms Rukmani and evaluate their potential consequences. (c) Recommepay A'S cOinprehtstve strategy she should adopt to address' ' (d) Beyond law enforcement actions how can Ms. Rukmani foster sustainable change ut the socretal level to counter the drug menage? (20 marks 250 words)

    Topper: Reshma Nivetha · AIR 498 · 2025 · Page 41

  9. Open question 1029
    Q259 · 20 MARKS

    You are a senior police afliver ina bustling me in city known Jor its vibrant culture and vibrant streets. You live with your family in a lively neighbourhood and your extended family members often visit for gatherings and celebrytions In an unprecedented crisis a. deadly bio wegnon has been released in several parts of the city by unkown actors leading to a rapidly spreading aut The disease causes severe respiratory distress and neurological symptoms and medical scientists have yet to develop a cure or vaccine Panic has gripped the city mel a second wave of broewer ypon releave He WiuiecuorL BS poupic semunbte for safety a have intensified the fear The Wansportation network is crippled roads are blocked by abandoned vehicles metro and public buses have stopped functioning and all air and rail trgvel is suspended duc to biosafety protocols= Medical infrastructure is overstretched ith ". hospitals overwhelmed and medical stall jntected or quarantined You receive ai urgent communication from central command directing you to des ise and implementa physed evacuation plan. However due to the high contamination risk and limited availability of bio secure cvactation vehicles only a small number of people can be evacuated in cach round@Mimttiple operations wll be needed and every minute counts You have identified several priority groups that require evacuation. 1. ee including your spouse children elderly parents 2. Police personne! and emergency responders who have nisked their lives Maintaining order and arg now showing signs of fatigue and exposure. 3. Medical pemonnel und health volunteer including doctors nurses. and ambulance drivers who are ing to critical patignts. 4. Pr i wowen dilferently abled individuals children and the elderly at Tigh nak oF alt Gxpabee tonnes 5. Residents of a neighboring city who had traveled here (gr work or personal feasons and are now stuck due to border closures 6. Journalists and meWa personnel who are covering the crisis and heiping disseminate life saying information (a) What are the ethical dilemmas you will face in evacuation? (b) As a civil service officer of the state what would be the order in which you would evacuate these people and why? Give justifications ' (20 marks 250 words)

    Topper: Reshma Nivetha · AIR 498 · 2025 · Page 46

  10. Open question 1045
    Q260 · 10 MARKS

    a) "Integrity in isolation may ensure honesty but without impartiality and non partisanship governance cannot be ethical." Evaluate the interdependence of these foundational values in the context of public service. (10 marks 150 words)

    Topper: Praduman Bijalwan · AIR 501 · 2025 · Page 5