Toppers' CopiesPYQ

GS Paper 4 Toppers' Copies

All questions · 324 questions

  1. Open question 1056
    Q271 · 20 MARKS

    You are a senior civil servant in the Ministry of Information & Broadeasting. Your 17 year old daughter an intelligent and sensitive student of Class 12 has been an avid follower of popular influencers and motivational speakers. Recently she became deeply interested in a popular podcast show hosted by a well known social media figure Kunal Bhalla. T! show claims to champion "free thinking" and covers topics like hustle culture masculinity personal transformation and anti institutional narratives. Over time your daughter's behaviour begins to change. She withdraws from academic interests begins idolising internet influencers and adopts rigid opinions about success failure and mental health. She starts rejecting family advice refuses to appear for her board preparatory exams and argues that "school is irrelevant in the age of free minds." Concerned you and your spouse try to reason with her but she accuses you of being "closed minded." Matters come to head when you are alerted by your ministry's media monitoring cell about a viral video clip where your daughter is seen giving an interview on a fringe podcast platform endorsing radical views on education politics and civil services. The clip drew public attention because of your designation and journalists began speculating about a "generational rebellion" within the bureaucracy. Meanwhile the influencer Kunal Bhalla publicly praises your daughter as "the new voice of youth dissent " but refuses to take accountability for his platform's role in shaping her worldview. Social media is split some defend her right to free thought while others accuse such influencers of normalising disrespect for institutions and romanticizing shallow intellectualism. Your colleagues advice silence but your daughter now wants to drop out of school and intern with a podcast network. (a) What are the key ethical issues involved in the way "free thinking" is promoted by influencers on social media especially for impressionable youth? (b) What should be the role of public figures in responding to the misuse or distortion of influential platforms in the name of free expression? (c) Suggest a policy framework or guidelines for responsible influencer content aimed at youth without curbing intellectual freedom. (20 marks 250 words)

    Topper: Praduman Bijalwan · AIR 501 · 2025 · Page 46

  2. Open question 1057
    Q272 · 20 MARKS

    Raghav is the Chief Technology Officer (CTO) of a fast growing tech company in South Asia that designs and deploys AI systems for public services like education and policing. Recently the company secured a large government contract to implement facial recognition and predictive analytics systems in public schools and police departments. The project is significant for the company's growth and is being closely monitored by international investors and government agencies. However two major concerns have emerged. First internal audits show that the AI systems are not adequately trained on local data. They frequently misidentify individuals from tribal and minority backgrounds and unfairly flag behavioral issues among students from these communities. The software also lacks support for vernacular languages and neurodivergent users raising concerns about exclusion and discrimination. Second environmental groups have raised objections to the company's rising carbon footprint due to the expansion of energy intensive data centers. There has been a 42% increase in emissions over the last two years. Raghav now faces a serious ethical dilemma whether to push ahead with deployment to maintain momentum and company interests or pause and resolve these concerns knowing it may slow down progress and create internal friction. (a) Identify and discuss the ethical issues involved in the case. (b) Critically examine the options available to Raghav in this situation. (c) Which of the above options should Raghav adopt and why? Justify your answer using principles of ethics and professional responsibility. (20 marks 250 words)

    Topper: Praduman Bijalwan · AIR 501 · 2025 · Page 51

  3. Open question 1058
    Q273 · 20 MARKS

    A senior IAS officer recently appointed as chairperson of the NCR Clean Air Mission is tasked with addressing the escalating air pollution crisis in Delhi and neighboring regions where the Air Quality Index has reached hazardous levels. Scientific assessments point to multiple contributors i.e. stubble burning in nearby states construction related dust industrial emissions and diesel vehicle traffic. The officer proposes strict time bound restrictions including suspending construction activities limiting vehicular movement and enforcing crop residue burning bans. However these measures attract strong opposition from various stakeholders. Farmers cite a lack of alternatives real estate bodies warn of large scale job losses transport unions threaten strikes and political authorities express concerns over the potential impact on upcoming international investment events. Meanwhile health experts caution that delays will result in severe public health consequences especially for children and the elderly. The media criticizes the measures as elitist and anti poor. Caught between conflicting imperatives i.c. environmental protection economic livelihood public health and political viability the officer must now make a decision. (a) What are the options available to the officer to tackle the situation effectively / (b) What core values and principles should guide decision making in this scenario? (c) In such situations what long term institutional reforms would you suggest to reconcile environmental protection with developmental imperatives? (20 marks 250 words)

    Topper: Praduman Bijalwan · AIR 501 · 2025 · Page 56

  4. Open question 1184
    Q274 · 10 MARKS

    a) "Integrity in isolation may ensure honesty but without impartiality and non partisanship governance cannot be ethical." Evaluate the interdependence of these foundational values in the context of public service. (10 marks 150 words)

    Topper: Shiwani Kumari · AIR 578 · 2025 · Page 5

  5. Open question 1185
    Q275 · 10 MARKS

    Don't write (Don't write ane this part) this part) (b) "The essence of ethics in human actions involves a balance between individual autonomy and societal norms". Examine this statement by exploring how ethical frameworks reconcile personal freedom with social responsibility. (10 marks 150 words)

    Topper: Shiwani Kumari · AIR 578 · 2025 · Page 7

  6. Open question 1186
    Q276 · 10 MARKS

    a) Is conscience a universal moral compass or is it shaped by society and upbringing? Illustrate with suitable examples. (10 marks 150 words)

    Topper: Shiwani Kumari · AIR 578 · 2025 · Page 9

  7. Open question 1187
    Q277 · 10 MARKS

    Don't write (Don't write (b) How can the ethical principles rooted in ancient Indian philosophy serve as a guide for policymakers and administrators in balancing development with ecological sustainability? (10 marks 150 words)

    Topper: Shiwani Kumari · AIR 578 · 2025 · Page 11

  8. Open question 1188
    Q278 · 10 MARKS

    Given below are three quotations of great thinkers. What do each of these quotations convey to you in the present context? (a) Cultivation of mind should be the ultimate aim of human existence. Dr. B.R. Ambedkar (10 marks 150 words)

    Topper: Shiwani Kumari · AIR 578 · 2025 · Page 13

  9. Open question 1189
    Q279 · 10 MARKS

    srt sting this part) (c) Beneficence is a duty. He who frequently practices it and sees his benevolent intentions realized at length comes really to love him to whom "he has done good Immanuel Kant SOS (10 marks 150 words)

    Topper: Shiwani Kumari · AIR 578 · 2025 · Page 17

  10. Open question 1190
    Q280 · 10 MARKS

    a) "Technology is ethically neutral until we apply it." Discuss this statement with Teference to the ethical thical chalfenges pi posed by artificial intelligence and data privacy. (10 marks 150 words)

    Topper: Shiwani Kumari · AIR 578 · 2025 · Page 19